[Avodah] Parshanus: How Does one Construe Silence?

SBA sba at sba2.com
Tue Nov 20 07:03:47 PST 2007


From: "Richard Wolpoe" < >
Rashi at times uses Gematriyas.. countless Times that the Ba'al Hatuirm uses
a Gematriya where  Rashi does not use one.
   1. Is it fair to conclude that if Rashi wanted to, he WOULD have used
   the same Gematriya as the Tur?   Or
   2. Is Rashi's silence on a given Gmeatirya say nothing in particular?
   3. Is Rashi [or any parshan] always giving THE DEFINITIVE exhaustive
   peshat?   Or
   4. Is the Peirush simply selecting one of several valid options w/o
   necessarily rejecting other possible explanations?
>>>

#4. (and I suppose #1 as well.)

SBA






More information about the Avodah mailing list