[Avodah] Alleged story about the SM"A
Noah Witty
nwitty at optonline.net
Tue Oct 30 08:53:46 PDT 2007
There is "famous" story (I have heard it so it's "famous" . . . about
the SM"A who was involved in a din torah, which he lost despite his
acumen in Choshen Mishpat. The dayanim explained that they actually
paskened like the SM"A's own peirush on the matter, while the SM"A had,
in his own behalf, taken the position of the Sha"Ch, who disagrees with
the SM"A's peirush. The story is usualy conveyed as a moralality tale
about the blinding effect of self-interest (negi'os). (On the topic of
negi'os in this week's parsha, see Michtav May-Eliyahu, 2:202-203 and
5:299-300.)
QUERY: 1) Does anyone have a printed source for this story? If the
answer is Krohn, pleas identify the book, and possibly a printed source
earlier than Rav Shwadron zt"l.
2) Anyone have any idea what the din torah was about?
and what halacha was at issue?
Thanks in advance.
Noach Witty
More information about the Avodah
mailing list