[Avodah] Falling Tallis
Moshe Y. Gluck
mgluck at gmail.com
Mon Jul 9 20:06:23 PDT 2007
>>Two questions: 1) I recall seeing R' Moshe Feinstein say that in the case
>>where the Tallis inadvertently fell, one does _not_ have to repeat the
>>Berachah if he was wearing a Tallis Katan - not like the Be'er Heitiv.
Does
>>anyone remember such a thing, from RMF or someone else? (Yagati V'lo
>>Matzasi.) 2) I asked someone about this, and he said he recalled hearing
the
>>R' Yaakov Kamenetzky said that the current Minhag is not to repeat the
>>Berachah should one's Tallis fall. Can anyone corroborate this?
R' Neventzal shilt"a, in his sefer on the Mishna Brurah, says in the
name of RSZA to not say a new bracha. His reasoning is that
the da''as of a person is that he will wear his tallis for all of davening
when he made the original brocha.
-- Mike
How does that reasoning trump the Mechaber and Ramah who clearly disagree
with it? Also, I'm not familiar with the Sefer you quote. What is it called?
More information about the Avodah
mailing list