[Avodah] violating a lav to perform a mitzva

Jacob Farkas jfarkas at compufar.com
Tue Feb 27 09:38:03 PST 2007


Rt. Chana Luntz wrote:
> I find myself constantly finding examples where I end up saying  - but 
> isn't this another case where there seems to be an assumption that if we 
> are doche a Torah mizvah, a rabbinic mizvah kama v'kama, but anyway - 
> you are more than welcome to join me on my hunt.

The Qal Vahomer is not valid because Hakhamim Asu Hizuq Lidivreihem 
Yoser Mishel Torah. It is therefore possible to apply dehiya for a 
D'Oraisa, but not for a D'Rabbanan.

--Jacob Farkas



More information about the Avodah mailing list