[Avodah] Electricity on Shabbos

[Dov Kay]

<<I don't recall the CI saying that. In fact, that sevara has been rejected 
l'halacha at least by tevilas keilim. One acharon suggested that a toaster 
would be patur from tevilas keilim because it is mechubar l'karka (plugged 
in) and everyone else disagreed.>>

I have heard that a Dayan in London does in fact pasken that toasters do not 
need to be immersed based on this sevara, so I would have to disagree with 
your "everyone else disagreed".  Perhaps they disagreed at the time and this 
Dayan thought it was a good sevara after all.  By the way, who is the 
acharon?

Kol tuv
Dov Kay

_________________________________________________________________
Match.com - Click Here To Find Singles In Your Area Today! 
http://msnuk.match.com/