[Avodah] [Areivim] Amen

[SBA]

From: Yitzchok Levine <>
http://www.geocities.com/m_yericho/ravkook/thisweek.htm
. Please note the section A Quiet Amen.

I recall Rav A. Miller learning a Tosephos in a
shiur that I attended many years ago that said
something similar. When I asked him,  "In light
of this Tosephos, why do some people say Amen
very loudly?"  he gave me one of his knowing smiles, but did not comment.
:-)
>>>

The halocho is clear that one should not say Amen louder than the Shatz.
But in a case where there is noise or some of the mispallelim are talking 
etc,
 I thought it would be OK.

Tonight I saw that the MB (124:47) indeed paskens so.
"Nireh de'im kavonosoy beharimo koloy kedei lezarez ha'am
sheyaanu gam hem - mutar..."

SBA