[Avodah] [Areivim] URL: article about halachic

[A & C Walters]

The Rishonim in beginning of Ish Mekadah ask how can the gemoro bring a
statement from mishbeh "isha miskadeshes bo ubeshulcho" the gemoro learns
"mitzvah b yoser etc" Lechoro she doesn't have a mitzvah at all. Th Ritv"o
(I think) answers that she has a mitsvah mesayao, or a kium with no chiuyv.
Similar to makhlokos Rambam"m Rava"d if sh ecan make a brocho on mitzsvas
eisei shezman gromo.

Whilst yibum is only mutur alks "ei efshar lkeem beinyan acher" there is
nevertheless a dimyon to Kelaium be'tzitzis which is not. Also, I never said
that this case was ADL"S. (because it's not IELKBI"A) only that if it was,
it would be for the woman also.

R' Elchonon in Kovetz HaOros samech tes, ois chof hei to chof ches that Tos'
asks the question that the issur (of lo yiye koydesh) occurs betchilas bilah
whereas the mitzvah (pru vrvu) occurs only at sof bila, therefore it is not
docheh. R' Elchonon asks that lechoroh the kium mitzvah is only beshas
leiada, and he says that the mayseh mitzveh is what is needed, not the kium.
Also he brings the Ra"n which says that the techilas meisah mitzvah is
docheh, and the same thing here.

----------------------------------------------------------------------
Click to get free info on kitchen remodeling at 50% - 70% off
http://tagline.bidsystem.com/fc/KCuXzzUQCQzcZsF4Is9nBqV2QjGY7b/