[Avodah] Astounding Meshech Chochma, Parev Meat?

[Rabbi Meir]

Rabbosay,

 

Has anyone noticed the Meshech Chochma [opening P VaYera] discussing the
angels eating bassar BeChaLav under AA supervision?

He appears to consider that meat of a Ben Pekuah is not flieshig.

 

In explaining the exchange between Moshe"R and the Malochim, when they
protested MosheR taking the Torah, the response of M"R was that the Malochim
had already accepted Avraham as a Yisroel who could therefore exercise the
din [power] of Shechita to produce a Ben Pekuah which is not flieshig and
that's why the Malochim could eat and why A"A could cook and benefit from
what would otherwise have been Bassar BeChalav.

Had he been considered by the Malochim as a Ben Noach it would have been
assur as Bassar BeChalav, to cook, eat or benefit since they had undertaken
keeping all 613 Mitzvos (voluntarily?) and without Kedushas Yisroel the
cutting of the throat would not be Shechita and could not produce a BP.

 

The M"Ch save for referring to the ShaAr HaMelech who maintains that the
MILK of a BP is not milchig brings no proof for this.  One is tempted to
read the M"Ch's proposal as the MILK was of a BP but I feel that is forced.
He, in the first instance is discussing the "ben habokor" ie the meat AA
prepared for his visitors and says, that was BP meat upon which there is no
prohibition of Bassar BeChalav.

 

A friend showed me a Sefer, Kosnos Or, which on the title page is named
MeOrey Eish, by Elozor Av BD of KK Zablodova [also author of Shut Panim
Me'iros - could someone please tell me more about him]: who suggests that
from the Mishnah Chullin 113; those things that have Tum'as Neveilo i.e.
including birds, are within the prohibition of BBeChalav. He argues that
BPekuah can not be Neveilo and may therefore be cooked with milk. He says
this is written explicitly in the Sefer Mem Aleph [who is that?] and is
possibly agreed to by all.

 

 

 

meir

 

-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: <http://lists.aishdas.org/pipermail/avodah-aishdas.org/attachments/20061123/29ff9114/attachment-0001.htm>