[Avodah] To Stand or Not to Stand for a Chosson and Kallah
Prof. Levine
llevine at stevens.edu
Thu Nov 3 06:52:52 PDT 2011
At 09:34 AM 11/3/2011, M Cohen wrote:
>RYL asked .. If it is indeed the case that we stand when people are going
>to do a
>mitzvah, then why don't we stand when the Baal Kriah gets up to
>lein, when the Baal Shachris goes to the Amud to daven, etc. ?
>
>indeed, r Yaakov kamanetsky writes that the minhag to stand for az yashir
>in pesukei d'zimra is to honor those going to give tzedah at that that time.
Most people stand well before Az Yashir at v'yevorech Dovid. However,
this standing is optional.
>Mordechai cohen
>
>As for your question, what mitva/chiuv is Baal Shachris davening, Baal Kriah
>leining, etc ?
Are you saying that there is no mitzva to read the Torah on Mondays,
Thursdays and on Shabbos? Is there no mitzva to daven with a minyan
and hence the person leading the davening is not doing a mitzvah?
What about someone who puts on tefillin standing? Is he not doing a
mitzvah, yet people do not stand for someone putting on tefillin.
YL
More information about the Avodah
mailing list