[Avodah] More Tzaar

David Riceman driceman at optimum.net
Fri Oct 28 11:42:01 PDT 2011


RMB:

<<However, lemaaseh, he did wake up his son. So, along the way we have 
enough information to deduce something other than RMS's point. The 
future RYBS was wrong -- being asleep and requiring waking isn't the 
kind of tza'ar included by mitzta'er patur min hasukkah.

  If it were patur min hasukkah, RMS wouldn't have had to force his son 
to show up, even if the booth while being a rained upon isn't a halachic 
sukkah.>>

There's no p'tur of mitztaer on the first night! How is this a proof of 
anything?

David Riceman






More information about the Avodah mailing list