[Avodah] Klalei horaah

[Daniel Eidensohn]

I agree he is denying the premise. I simply said he raises the question. 
There is another view that the Talmud was edited to conform with the 
klalei horaah. In other words according to this view the Talmud is not a 
historically accurate record of who said what

Micha Berger wrote:
> Where are you reading from? To me it looks like he denies the premise... The
> kelalei pesaq are not the hard-n-fast rules of an algorithm, but the
> rules-of-thumb of a heuristic. (Search the list for that word to see RRW's
> and my long debate on that subject.)
>
> I