[Avodah] Horaas Shaah

[Moshe Y. Gluck]

R' MB:
Clearly RBBL didn't know German, and little of RSRH's writings were
available in Hebrew.

R' YL:
I simply do not understand how anyone can decide something as important as TIDE being or not being Horaas Shaah without having read a fair amount of the writings of RSRH. 
------------

One can decide whether TIDE is or is not Horaas Shaah without reading a fair amount of RSRH's writings by knowing lots and lots of Shas, Rishonim, Acharonim, Poskim, Baalei Mussar and Baalei Machshavah. I daresay that both RSRH and RBBL were well qualified in that regard, and their disagreement (if, indeed, RSRH did not mean TIDE as HS) is a manifestation of Shivim Panim, rather than, CV, RBBL's implied ignorance/carelessness.

KT,
MYG