[Avodah] Girl Scout cookies

[Akiva Blum]

RRW wrote:
>>>
Nire'h li pashut that it is problematic to add the cookies to a feligshig recpie if one constgrues that the original bittul of the whey is construed as bemeizid.
<<

Not so poshut. With nat bar nat, even where the process was done with intention to mix with meat, which is ossur to do (Y.D.95 Shach 3, Taz 4), we do not find that it is ossur bedieved since there is no real issur to be mevatel cholov in parve.

>>>
Nire'h li pashut if you do NOT consture the manufacturer as being mevateil
bemeizid that you may be mevatil it lechatchila [see Ba'ei Hetev in the name
of the Tach]
<<<

Could you please be a little more specific as to that source. There's a lot of BH in YD.

Anyway, even if you do not construe the manufacturer as being mevateil
bemeizid, then kol shekein it's already bottul.


>>>
Nir'eh li pashut that to EAT said cookie after meat - even if the original
bittul was bemiezied - should be ok.[At most one should wait an hour.] We
ashkenazim hold that waiting is minhag not halachah, and there is not reason
to be machmir if the whey is battel.

The humra of waiting for a tacvshil of chlaval was added onlater andis NOT
mei'ikkar hadin anyway. Thus, Sephardim who must wati 6 hours midin need
not wait becasue this is not halav but a tavshil at most

S'nif to be meikel is tosafos who requries Zero waiting is required [so
Behag and is the original Meimra/P'sak of Rabbi Yochanan before emended to
conform with Rav Chisdah]

Kein Nir'eh lefi aniyas da'ati
<<<

As above, you can eat it with meat mamash. It's 100% parve.

BTW, if it has only 1% milk, so it should be botul, but all that milk is in the chocolate chip only, then you have a problem. You also have a reasonable explanation why that put in a ta'am that would be botul.

Akiva