[Avodah] Chiyuv l'kabel gerim
Moshe Y. Gluck
mgluck at gmail.com
Sun Jan 6 20:25:06 PST 2008
R' YGB:
You call that Chazal? I call that Tanach!
Be that as it may, that was because they were assumed not to be megayer
l'shma. Vohs hoht dohs tzu tohn miht uhnz?
Yes, I call that Chazal, too.
In my experience speaking to Rabbanim who are/were Osek in Geirus (and I
invite the Rabbanim on-list to say their experiences) it is often very easy
to suspect a She'lo Lishma, even today. That apparently is one of the big
objections that some people have against the new group headed by R' Leib
Tropper which seeks to convert non-Jewish spouses of Jews. That said, I was
just bringing the Rambam as a data point, more than anything else.
If it is a Chiyuv to be Mekabel Geirim, why did Shammai not have a bit more
patience with the prospective Ger? True, he may have been rude or uncouth,
but perhaps Shammai could have educated him?
KT,
MYG
More information about the Avodah
mailing list